Convicted Murderer Colton Pitonyak Given Chance for New Trial - KiiiTV.com South Texas, Corpus Christi, Coastal Bend

Convicted Murderer Colton Pitonyak Given Chance for New Trial

Posted: Updated:
AUSTIN (Kiii News) -

More than six years after he went to jail for the murder of Jennifer Cave, a former University of Texas student and Carroll High School graduate, Colton Pitonyak's lawyers dropped a bombshell this week, and it may be enough to get him another trial.

Pitonyak's attorneys said that his friend, Laura Hall, who is serving 10 year for tampering with evidence, gave a confession to two inmates, who then reported that information to the jail counselors. They said that the information was documented, but never turned over to the defense.

On Tuesday, the fifth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals agreed to give Pitonyak's attorneys a hearing to prove why he deserves a new trial.

The district attorney would not go into specifics, but is agreeing to test some evidence previously not tested, and some evidence will be retested.

It was back in August of 2005 when 21-year old Jennifer Cave was stabbed and dismembered. It happened in Pitonyak's bathtub. He was later convicted and given a 55-year sentence.

Pitonyak's friend Laura Hall is serving 10 years for tampering with evidence.

Cave's mother, Sharon, still lives here in Corpus Christi.

"A jury, in Travis County, of 12 people found Colton Pitonyak guilty, and a jury of 12 people, in Travis County, sentenced him to 55 years," Sharon Cave said over the phone. "I stand behind that jury for all the hard work that they did, and I will stand behind that jury and their decisions."

There has been no word as to when that hearing will take place.

  • 3 African-Americans on 12-person grand jury weighing Ferguson shooting case

    3 African-Americans on 12-person grand jury weighing Ferguson shooting case

    Saturday, August 23 2014 1:13 PM EDT2014-08-23 17:13:19 GMT
    FERGUSON, Missouri (CNN) -- Ever since it happened, race has been front-and-center in the vigorous debate over the fatal shooting of African-American teenager Michael Brown by a white police officer.Could it also factor into those 12 people now deciding whether that Ferguson, Missouri, officer will face charges in the 18-year-old's death?We may never know. That's because the St. Louis County grand jury weighing the case meets, per established rules, in private.Still, at least we found out Fri...More >>
    FERGUSON, Missouri (CNN) -- Ever since it happened, race has been front-and-center in the vigorous debate over the fatal shooting of African-American teenager Michael Brown by a white police officer.Could it also factor into those 12 people now deciding whether that Ferguson, Missouri, officer will face charges in the 18-year-old's death?We may never know. That's because the St. Louis County grand jury weighing the case meets, per established rules, in private.Still, at least we found out Fri...More >>
  • Shooting Suspect Leads CCPD Officers On Chase Toward Border

    Shooting Suspect Leads CCPD Officers On Chase Toward Border

    Two people were shot on Friday night and the suspect then lead police on a high speed car chase that ended down by the Sarita Border Patrol checkpoint. But the search for the shooter is far from over.More >>
    Two people were shot on Friday night and the suspect then lead police on a high speed car chase that ended down by the Sarita Border Patrol checkpoint. But the search for the shooter is far from over.More >>
  • Corpus Christi 7 Day Film Project Screening

    Corpus Christi 7 Day Film Project Screening

    Production has wrapped and the films are in the can and ready to be screened! Saturday morning, 7 Day Film Project organizer Omar Becerra joined 3 News Anchor Michael Gibson to talk about those local movies. 36 entries still left in the running for a number of awards up for grabs.More >>
    Production has wrapped and the films are in the can and ready to be screened! Saturday morning, 7 Day Film Project organizer Omar Becerra joined 3 News Anchor Michael Gibson to talk about those local movies. 36 entries still left in the running for a number of awards up for grabs.More >>