Monsanto Wins Patent Case, Could Have Big Impact on Biotech - KiiiTV.com South Texas, Corpus Christi, Coastal Bend

Monsanto Wins Patent Case, Could Have Big Impact on Biotech

Posted: Updated:

WASHINGTON (CNN) - The Supreme Court ruled for agribusiness giant Monsanto on Monday in a patent case that could have an enormous impact on a variety of biotech fields.

The justices unanimously found the world's largest seed producer has intellectual property control over its best-selling "Roundup Ready" soybeans. That means the product cannot be reproduced without paying the company a fee.

Products like genetically engineered seeds and live vaccines have been hailed as scientific and industrial breakthroughs, but they often can be reproduced easily and cheaply.

Monsanto sued an Indiana farmer, Vernon Hugh Bowman, claiming he violated a farming agreement when he used genetic copies of the company's soybean product without paying a "technology fee."

Monsanto claimed that the seeds could only be used for one growing season, meaning their offspring could not be saved and replanted without compensation.

The high court agreed.

"Bowman planted Monsanto's patented soybeans solely to make and market replicas of them thus depriving the company of the reward patent law provides for the sale of each article," said Justice Elena Kagan.

The high court is deciding a separate case on whether human genes can be patented.

Monsanto dominates the soybean seed market. Its Roundup Ready variety is used to grow about 90 percent of the nation's crop for the estimated 275,000 American soybean farmers like Bowman, according to its petition.

The company's scientists perfected a system in 1996 for injecting genes into seeds that are resistant to the herbicide Roundup. This allowed farmers to plant with reduced risk of weeds, insects, and disease.

Those soybeans cost more and farmers must agree not to replant their progeny, thus buying seeds each year.

The corporation says it has sued 146 U.S. farmers including Bowman. Eleven cases have gone to trial and Monsanto won them all.

Bowman grows corn, wheat, and soybeans on 300 acres in Sandborn, Indiana.

He used the patented soybeans for his main spring crop, but went to a local grain elevator and purchased so-called commodity seeds for a riskier, late-season crop.

Such soybeans are typically used for feed livestock and for milling, but not for replanting.

But Bowman said there were no restrictions on how he used the mixed-variety seeds, which he did for eight consecutive fall crops.

The company found out and sued him six years ago was awarded more than $84,000 in damages. Lower courts said the second-generation seed planting was a "newly infringing article."

Mark Walters, Bowman's attorney, said farmers take all the risks when they plant, while the company can sit back and control how its products are used in perpetuity.

"If exhaustion [first-sale doctrine] is eliminated, rather, for the progeny seed, then you are taking away the ability of people to exchange these goods freely in commerce," he told the court during February oral arguments.

"You have essentially a servitude on these things that are exchanged and every grain elevator who makes a sale is infringing," he said.

Food safety experts have raised concerns about the proliferation of genetically engineered food products, saying such production technologies can prove harmful.

But Monsanto, backed by the Obama administration and a range of businesses, say protecting intellectual property is more important than ever, especially in fast-developing technological fields.

"America's leadership in fostering the incentive to invest in research and development has created the world's leading innovation economy, with millions of high-technology jobs-not just in our field of agriculture, but in other R&D-intensive fields like medicine, biotechnology, computer science and environmental science," said David Snively, Monsanto's general counsel.

Bowman argued the soybeans naturally replicate or sprout themselves and had done so without much input from him.

But Kagan, writing for her eight colleagues, was not convinced.

"We think that blame-the-bean defense tough to credit," she said. "In all this, the bean surely figured. But it was Bowman, and not the bean, who controlled the reproduction (to the eighth generation) of Monsanto's patented invention."

But Kagan also issued a measure of caution, saying this decision might not necessarily apply in other areas.

"Our holding today is limited -- addressing the situation before us, rather than every one involving a self-replicating product," she said. "We recognize that such inventions are becoming ever more prevalent, complex, and diverse."

The case is Bowman v. Monsanto Company (11-796).

  • Services Held for Well-Known Businessman Benjamin Mustafa

    Services Held for Well-Known Businessman Benjamin Mustafa

    Family, friends and community members came together Wednesday evening to remember 59-year old Benjamin Mustafa, the victim of this city's latest homicide.A memorial was held for the beloved and well-known businessman, who was fatally shot last week at the Tim's Market on Ayers Street. Services took place at the Bay Area Fellowship on Rodd Field Road.Kiii News Reporter Bill Churchwell went Live from the memorial services with more information.To many, he was simply known as Ben, or Benjamin, a...More >>
    Family, friends and community members came together Wednesday evening to remember 59-year old Benjamin Mustafa, the victim of this city's latest homicide.A memorial was held for the beloved and well-known businessman, who was fatally shot last week at the Tim's Market on Ayers Street. Services took place at the Bay Area Fellowship on Rodd Field Road.Kiii News Reporter Bill Churchwell went Live from the memorial services with more information.To many, he was simply known as Ben, or Benjamin, a...More >>
  • Students Bound for Rome to Witness Canonization Ceremony

    Students Bound for Rome to Witness Canonization Ceremony

    Some lucky Coastal Bend residents, including students and teachers from John Paul II High School, are on their way to Rome to witness history.Pope John Paul II will be canonized on Sunday, and our own citizen reports from John Paul II High School will be there to watch. About 70 members of the community boarded buses Wednesday morning heading for Houston, where they will catch a plane to Rome.Pope John Paul II and Pope John the 23rd will be proclaimed saints at the ceremony at the Vatican Sun...More >>
    Some lucky Coastal Bend residents, including students and teachers from John Paul II High School, are on their way to Rome to witness history.Pope John Paul II will be canonized on Sunday, and our own citizen reports from John Paul II High School will be there to watch. About 70 members of the community boarded buses Wednesday morning heading for Houston, where they will catch a plane to Rome.Pope John Paul II and Pope John the 23rd will be proclaimed saints at the ceremony at the Vatican Sun...More >>
  • Male TAMUK Students Walk a Mile in Heels for a Good Cause

    Male TAMUK Students Walk a Mile in Heels for a Good Cause

    Male students at Texas AM University-Kingsville got a taste Wednesday of what women have to deal with everyday -- walking in high heels.It was an event called Walk a Mile in Her Shoes, which aims at showing support for the cause of ending gender violence and sexual assault."It's difficult just standing here in high heels, honestly," TAMUK sophomore Steven Garza said. "My feet hurt, and I don't know how I'm going to walk a mile, honestly.""It actually is pretty difficult," TAMUK sophomore Adri...More >>
    Male students at Texas AM University-Kingsville got a taste Wednesday of what women have to deal with everyday -- walking in high heels.It was an event called Walk a Mile in Her Shoes, which aims at showing support for the cause of ending gender violence and sexual assault."It's difficult just standing here in high heels, honestly," TAMUK sophomore Steven Garza said. "My feet hurt, and I don't know how I'm going to walk a mile, honestly.""It actually is pretty difficult," TAMUK sophomore Adri...More >>
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and KIII. All Rights Reserved.
For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.