Starbucks goes after pub for 'Frappicino beer"; pub sends $6, hi - KiiiTV.com South Texas, Corpus Christi, Coastal Bend

Starbucks goes after pub for 'Frappicino beer"; pub sends $6, hilarious response

Posted:
STORY HIGHLIGHTS
  • The beer is vanilla creme and chocolate coffee ale
  • A customer calls it Frappicino
  • Briton sends Starbucks $6 to "make amends"
  • The company says it won't cash the check

By Emma Lacey-Bordeaux and Dave Alsup

You've probably heard this one before: Little guy gets too close to a trademark held by a big company. Big company threatens legal action. Little guy backs off.

But have you heard the one where the small business owner responds to a cease and desist order from Starbucks with a satirical letter and a check for $6?

At issue: A craft beer called "Frappicino."

But we're getting ahead of ourselves. Let's start at the beginning.

Jeff Briton owns the Exit 6 Pub and Brewery in Cottleville, Missouri. He has for two and a half years. The place isn't a fancy gastro pub, in fact, it doesn't even have a kitchen.

It does one thing and does it well: serve craft beer seven days a week, starting at 4 p.m.

A beer is born

Last January, Briton mixed two of his creations together: A vanilla crème and a chocolate coffee ale.

The result, according to a customer, tasted a whole lot like a certain blended coffee ice beverage served at the more than 5,500 Starbucks locations worldwide.

The customer wrote about the creation on a beer website, Un Tapped, and called it a "Frappicino" -- one letter off from the Starbucks trademarked name.

Fast forward 11 months.

Cease and desist

Last week, Briton received a letter from Starbucks' lawyers, asking him to stop using the name.

"The FRAPPICINO mark only differs from Starbucks Coffee Co.'s FRAPPUCCINO mark by one letter," the letter said, "and is phonetically identical."

The bar's use of the name would cause "confusion" among buyers, it added.

The message was clear: you violated our trademark. Stop.

But in the black and white legalese, Briton saw an opportunity.

"This huge law firm sends me this letter," Briton told CNN on Monday night. "How many hours did that lawyer have to spend in sending that out?"

Briton says he reckons that Starbucks spent more in law firm billable hours than he made in the entire month of December.

In other words, Briton felt he had to respond.

'We're poor spelers'

Addressing his response to the lawyer and "Mr. Bucks," he referred to the offending beverage and trademark as "The F Word" so as to fend of further litigation risk.

"It has recently come to the Exit 6 Pub and Brewerys attention that there were 3 check ins to the beer with a very similar name to the "F Word". Unfortunately it was only similar to the F Word because we meant to call it the same thing. Lucky for us, we're poor spelers."

"We just feel awful about calling a beer the F Word," the letter went on. "We are bad people. We feel shame."

And while Briton wrote that he would stop calling the beer "The F Word," he also wanted to reassure Mr. Bucks that he and his customers meant no harm.

"I guess that with there being a Starbucks on every corner of every block in every city that some people may think they could get a Starbucks at a local bar," he wrote. "So that was our mistake."

Check in the mail

Briton said he wanted to make amends.

So, in an effort to "remain in good standings," he included a check for the "full amount of profit gained" from sales of the offending brew.

Total number of beers sold: three. The check to Starbucks: $6.

People love stories about little guys standing up to corporations with big pockets. And soon, Briton's story was splashed all over mainstream media.

"Even someone very inebriated should not find coffee and beer to be confusingly similar," wrote Mike Sandburg on the bar's Facebook page.

Added Mindy Schildroth: "I think you should name your next beer Six Bucks!"

And Martin Lawler said he'd fly from Oakhurst, California, just to order the beer. "And I don't like stouts!!"

Request was 'respectful'

Laurel Harper, a manager for Starbucks communication, told CNN the request her company sent to Briton was "respectful."

"Just like many business, trademark law requires all companies, including Starbucks, to consistently protect its brand," she said via e-mail. "We always prefer to resolve trademark disputes informally and amicably whenever possible, and we appreciate Exit 6 Pub and Brewery respecting our request to avoid confusion among customers."

Harper told CNN she hadn't heard about Briton's check. She said Starbucks wouldn't be cashing it.

The experience prompted Briton to stop producing another beer, he said tongue planted firmly in cheek:

The "Starbuck-McDonalds-Coca Cola-Marlboro Honey Lager."

The-CNN-Wire
™ & © 2013 Cable News Network, Inc., a Time Warner Company. All rights reserved.

  • Basketball Team Shows Support for Coach Battling Parkinson's Disease

    Basketball Team Shows Support for Coach Battling Parkinson's Disease

    If you know anyone who's battled Parkinson's Disease, you know how difficult the disease is. On Saturday, dozens of people raised awareness and money for research to help those who are living with Parkinson's right here in the Coastal Bend. Bright and early, kayak races were held at Billish Park on Padre Island. The event is called Paddle for Parkinson's. The money raised will help support local people who are battling the disease such as "Coach K" who coaches high school basketball in Port...More >>
    If you know anyone who's battled Parkinson's Disease, you know how difficult the disease is. On Saturday, dozens of people raised awareness and money for research to help those who are living with Parkinson's right here in the Coastal Bend. Bright and early, kayak races were held at Billish Park on Padre Island. The event is called Paddle for Parkinson's. The money raised will help support local people who are battling the disease such as "Coach K" who coaches high school basketball in Port...More >>
  • Pet Owner Arrested, Accused of Cutting off Dog's Leg

    Pet Owner Arrested, Accused of Cutting off Dog's Leg

    New developments this weekend in connection with an animal cruelty case we've been tell you about. Police say they have arrested the pet's owner who is accused of cutting off the dog's leg. 48 year old Steven Mulligan has been charged with animal cruelty and is in jail in lieu of a $25,000 dollar bond. The dog's name is Bugsy. Investigators say Mulligan, in an attempt to deal with an infection in the dog's leg, gave the dog a human pain killer, and then proceeded to cut it off. The director ...More >>
    New developments this weekend in connection with an animal cruelty case we've been tell you about. Police say they have arrested the pet's owner who is accused of cutting off the dog's leg. 48 year old Steven Mulligan has been charged with animal cruelty and is in jail in lieu of a $25,000 dollar bond. The dog's name is Bugsy. Investigators say Mulligan, in an attempt to deal with an infection in the dog's leg, gave the dog a human pain killer, and then proceeded to cut it off. The director ...More >>
  • Police Successfully Prevent a Woman from Jumping off the Harbor Bridge

    Police Successfully Prevent a Woman from Jumping off the Harbor Bridge

    Some tense moments for Corpus Christi Police as they tried to prevent a woman from jumping off the top of the Harbor Bridge. It happened around 4 Saturday afternoon, when police say a 47 year old woman stepped over the rail and attempted to commit suicide. Police quickly responded and closed off several lanes of the Harbor Bridge. The officers called in the hostage negotiation team and had the Marina Patrol shut down the Port of Corpus Christi for a brief time. Fire fighters assisted in tryi...More >>
    Some tense moments for Corpus Christi Police as they tried to prevent a woman from jumping off the top of the Harbor Bridge. It happened around 4 Saturday afternoon, when police say a 47 year old woman stepped over the rail and attempted to commit suicide. Police quickly responded and closed off several lanes of the Harbor Bridge. The officers called in the hostage negotiation team and had the Marina Patrol shut down the Port of Corpus Christi for a brief time. Fire fighters assisted in tryi...More >>