Facebook Posts, Free Speech to Collide at Supreme Court - KiiiTV.com South Texas, Corpus Christi, Coastal Bend

Facebook Posts, Free Speech to Collide at Supreme Court

Posted: Updated:
(CNN) - The Supreme Court will explore the limits of "speech crimes" in the Internet age, especially laws aimed at protecting those harassed or bullied online.

The justices will hear oral arguments this fall in the prosecution of Anthony Elonis over Facebook posts.

Some were expressed as rap lyrics, which Elonis said were "therapeutic" for dealing with emotional pain.

But the federal government alleges he crossed a line in May 2010 and used threatening language about his estranged wife and an FBI agent investigating him.

"Did you know that it's illegal for me to say I want to kill my wife?" Elonis wrote. "It's illegal. It's indirect criminal contempt. It's one of the only sentences that I'm not allowed to say."

The justices will decide the level of proof needed to convict someone for making criminal threats.

The issue in play here has broader implications for free speech amid the explosion of popular and often anonymous social media.

Key questions here involve whether sites like Twitter are in the same category as more conventional news links, and are general threats made online different than those made in person?

Elonis exhibited what the government called "troubling behavior" at his work, including allegedly starting to undress in front of a female co-worker.

He was fired for posting a Facebook picture from a Halloween-themed event, where Elonis is holding a knife next to that co-worker, as part of the staged activities. The online caption read: "I wish."

His online postings became more graphic, including one obtained by prosecutors in which Elonis wrote about his wife.

A court later granted a protection-from-abuse order filed by his spouse.

Other postings, by now being monitored by the FBI, were aimed at judges and law enforcement involved in the case. They also included a reference to school shootings.

Elonis was convicted in federal court and sentenced to 44 months in prison. He appealed.

The government told the high court that this was not a case of "careless talk, exaggeration, something said in a joking manner or an outburst of transitory anger. The statements that qualify as true threats (from the defendant) thus have a significant, serious character."

But Elonis' lawyers said the government did not prove his statements showed a "subjective intent to threaten," based on previous Supreme Court precedent. And they question whether "a reasonable person would regard the statement as threatening."

His lawyers said Elonis was simply exercising free-speech.

"Although the language was, as with popular rap songs addressing the same themes, sometimes violent, (the) petitioner posted explicit disclaimers in his profile explaining that his posts were 'fictitious lyrics,' they said.

"Art is about pushing limits. I'm willing to go to jail for my constitutional rights. Are you?" he asked at one point.

The court's docket has increasingly included constitutional disputes over the limits of digital and online technology. The justices are currently writing a ruling on whether police can obtain evidence of criminal activity from a suspect's cellphone without first obtaining a search warrant.

  • Police Investigating Latest Shooting

    Police Investigating Latest Shooting

    Tuesday, September 16 2014 12:10 AM EDT2014-09-16 04:10:28 GMT
    A 19-year-old man is recovering after being shot in the abdomen at Los Encinos Park Monday evening. Police say the victim and a 17-year-old suspect got into a fight when a shot was fired.More >>
    A 19-year-old man is recovering after being shot in the abdomen at Los Encinos Park Monday evening. Police say the victim and a 17-year-old suspect got into a fight when a shot was fired.More >>
  • Boater Rescued Speaks Out

    Boater Rescued Speaks Out

    Tuesday, September 16 2014 12:06 AM EDT2014-09-16 04:06:00 GMT
    It's an amazing story of survival as one man survives in opening waters for more than 24 hours after the fishing boat he was in sank. Joey Trevino spoke to our Mike DaSilva about how he survived.More >>
    It's an amazing story of survival as one man survives in opening waters for more than 24 hours after the fishing boat he was in sank. Joey Trevino spoke to our Mike DaSilva about how he survived.More >>
  • Homicide Survivors Group Offers Support to Residents Affected by Triple Homicide

    Homicide Survivors Group Offers Support to Residents Affected by Triple Homicide

    Sunday night's triple homicide is not only affecting the family members of the victims who died, but also the residents who heard the gunfire and watched the shooting play out in front of them. Members of a homicide survivors support group spent much of the day at the Marina Village RV Park in Flour Bluff where the crime took place. The group was there trying to console those neighbors who remain in shock. Luci McGuire told 3 News reporter Bill Churchwell, "right now they are all scared. Thi...More >>
    Sunday night's triple homicide is not only affecting the family members of the victims who died, but also the residents who heard the gunfire and watched the shooting play out in front of them. Members of a homicide survivors support group spent much of the day at the Marina Village RV Park in Flour Bluff where the crime took place. The group was there trying to console those neighbors who remain in shock. Luci McGuire told 3 News reporter Bill Churchwell, "right now they are all scared. Thi...More >>